Previously Submitted Q's & A's for 2010
General:
Q1: Will
the location of the contest be handicap accessible?
A1:
The location of the contest this year will be the Union College Field House
that is handicap accessible.
Q2:What is the definition of a Goldberg Machine?
A2:
Please read the BACKGROUND
section of the web site to get a sense of who Rube Goldberg was
and what made his cartoons so popular. A Rube Goldberg
device is one that captures the spirit
of Rube Goldberg's ability to take a simple task and make it complex.
Q3: What age groups
are being asked to participate?
A3: This competition
is targeted at Middle and High School students.
Q4: Do you
have to live in a certain area to enter the contest?
A4: No.
Q5: Is each
school limited to one team?
A5: Schools
are allowed to have more than one team enter the competition. We would
prefer that the number of entries from any one school not to exceed 2 or
3.
Q6: Are
there divisions for middle school students to compete in? If not can
they still compete in regular contest?
A6: In the previous competitions we
have not separated the middle school and high school students into
separate divisions. Middle schools have won the competition in the
past. We may consider having a middle school and a high school
division if the number of schools grows to the point were dividing the
competition up would be more efficient.
After Registering:
Q7: How
detailed should the step-by-step description be? Does it need to include
illustrations and detailed drawings? Does the description hold any
weight in the final score? How do we submit it?
A7: The step-by-step descriptions do
not have to include detailed drawings, but drawings can be included.
The step-by-step description does not directly enter into the final
scoring. It may be sent as hardcopy along with the required Release Form or via email
to Prof. Jim Hedrick at hedrickj@union.edu.
Q8: When do we get the 100 dollar check?
A8:
The $100 stipend per team is distributed to the team's school district or organization after
the completed and signed Release Form (see the Rules page) and the step-by-step
description of the device is submitted and accepted. Advisors should make arrangements
for expenditures and reimbursement with the district or organization.
Check the SCHEDULE page for dates.
Some design/scoring issues:
Q9: Does
the theme affect the aesthetics of the machine or the function?
A9: The theme can be part of the
aesthetics and/or function of the machine. The more the theme is
integrated into the machine the more creativity points the machine will
be awarded. Please consult the judging form
to understand how your team is able to accumulate points during the competition.
Q10: How
much assembly time is allowed?
A10: The
competition schedule allows for one hour for the initial assembly time.
After this time the machines are not allowed to be altered until the judges
are prepared to evaluate it.
Q11: What is the criteria
for, or definition of, a "step"?
A11: A step is
a linear process, not a parallel process. If a plane moves up a wire
and triggers a switch, that would be an example of one complete step. If
the plane causes two things to happen, that would be a parallel result
and would only count as one complete step.
Q12:
If you have a series of dominos does each domino
hitting the next one count as an individual step? (If you had 6 dominos
each hitting another one, would you then have 6 steps?)
A12: This would be considered a single step since the process is the dominos hitting each other.
Q13: Is electrical to fluid motion an acceptable form of energy conversion?
A13: Yes.
Some safety issue examples:
Q14: As one of
the contest rules states, "No combustible fluids, explosives, open
flames, or hazardous materials." This is a fine rule, but would a
miniature potato gun be permissible? There would be no open flames, and
the projectile would at all times be encased in a plexy glass enclosure,
so as to prevent the projectile from go astray.
A14: This would be fine as long as no
combustible fluids or hazardous materials are used to propel the potato.
Also, you must be sure that all of projectiles are completely contained.
Q15: Can we use household bleach in our project?
A15:
The acceptability of using
household bleach in your project will depend on how the bleach will be
used. Since bleach can react violently with some substances, care
must be taken when it is used.
|